Oversharing Early in Dating: Finding the Right Pace for Personal Revelations

Return to The Squeeze

Entering the dating scene can feel like stepping into a spotlight on an empty stage—where every word counts, but the audience is just one person. Some of us respond to the intensity of this spotlight by revealing too much about ourselves too soon. It’s a common scenario: during the initial dates, instead of a gradual, gentle unveiling of our lives, thoughts, and feelings, there’s a sudden outpour. Why do we overshare, and how can we strike a healthier balance?

Why Do We Overshare?

The reasons for oversharing are as varied as the people who do it. For some, it’s about trying to connect quickly and deeply. There’s a compelling desire to accelerate intimacy, hoping that a flood of personal stories and secrets will bridge the gap between stranger and confidante overnight.

However, oversharing can also stem from anxiety. The nerves associated with early dates can make our filters less effective. In these moments, the brain, scrambling to find something to say, might latch onto a personal story or sensitive information. It’s a bit like filling an awkward silence with the first thought that comes to mind—only the thought is too personal, too soon.

Is Oversharing a Trauma Response?

In some cases, oversharing early in dating might be a trauma response. Those who have experienced relational trauma or instability might unconsciously use oversharing as a test or a shield. Revealing deep, personal information right away can be a way to gauge someone’s trustworthiness or to push them away—a protective mechanism disguised as an invitation.

Dating at a Healthier Pace

Finding a balance in how and when to share personal information can make dating more enjoyable and less stressful. Here are some strategies to help you pace yourself:

  1. Reflect on Your Motivations: Before you share something significant, pause and ask yourself why you want to share this information. Are you sharing because it feels like a natural extension of the conversation, or are you driven by anxiety, a desire to impress, or a need for validation?

  2. Set Personal Boundaries: It’s okay to have boundaries about what you’re comfortable sharing and when. You might decide not to discuss past relationships, family issues, or personal challenges until you’ve reached a certain level of comfort or trust with someone.

  3. Cultivate Awareness: Be mindful of the flow of the conversation. Is the sharing mutual? Are both parties opening up equally, or is one person doing all the talking? A balanced exchange can foster both comfort and closeness.

  4. Ask Questions: Instead of filling the space with your own stories, ask your date about their interests, experiences, and feelings. This not only helps balance the conversation but also builds a connection based on mutual curiosity and respect.

  5. Practice Patience: Developing intimacy takes time. Remind yourself that building trust and rapport gradually can lead to a more stable and satisfying relationship.

  6. Seek Feedback: If you’re unsure about the pace of your sharing, it can be helpful to discuss this with close friends or a therapist. They can offer insights into whether your sharing seems proportionate to the stage of your relationship.

Dating is not just about finding someone who clicks with your personality and shares your values; it’s also about timing and pacing your emotional revelations. Like a well-paced meal, where each course is savored, a relationship can be all the more satisfying when revelations are thoughtfully timed to deepen understanding and appreciation gradually.

Previous
Previous

On Vulnerability and Healing After Breakups

Next
Next

Dodging the Pitfalls of Future Tripping in Dating